During my e-mail correspondence with Westminster Councilman Kermit Marsh regarding the possibility of him running for the 1st Supervisor District (if it opens up), he sketched a quick analysis of the dynamics of the race:
The geographic breakdown would work against a Westminster or Garden Grove candidate. I finished first in Westminster, yet I still finished fourth district-wide. Bruce Broadwater finished first in Garden Grove, yet he finished a distant second behind Lou Correa. The key to the first district is Santa Ana, where Lou received more votes than Bruce, Brett and I combined. Despite much lower voter turnout in Santa Ana than in Westminster and Garden Grove, Santa Ana still accounted for 40% of the primary votes in March 2004.
To present a realistic candidacy, I think one would need either a powerful block of non-geographic voters (such as Van Tran's ability to carry nearly all of the Vietnamese American vote along with most non-Vietnamese American Republicans, or Joe Dunn's ability to draw almost the entirety of Democratic votes among all ethnicities) or a large and loyal constituency of the higher propensity voters in Santa Ana (such as Carlos Bustamante). A candidate whose support is concentrated in a single ethnicity or one of the smaller geographic entities (Westminster or Garden Grove) would probably not fare well in the general election, even if a crowded field would allow that person to make it past the primary. The candidate would also need to expend at least $200,000 to make it past the primary, or maybe a little less, if the field is truly crowded.